johnkilo's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[StarCraft: The Return]

Pretty good

I'll give a rundown. 8 in graphics because while they were good, they weren't the best. Style a 7 because its a pretty good movie, I definitely felt as if you were influenced by McFretN's CI: Unregulated, atleast in the opening scene. Obviously there was also an Aliens influence/reference. Sound a 7 because the voice acting could use a little pollishing. 8 in violence is obvious. 5 in interactivity because you included a handy scene select which I always like. 1 in humor. One thing I didn't like was that there was very little moviement in the characters, and a lot of the action seemed to be just "shakey cam." Except for the "3D" moments such as the tank turrent moving and such. I think you have skill, and if you just work on some areas, you could really have a top quality movie. I like Starcraft, so that is a plus. Good work.

LogFish responds:

I've never seen McFretN's thing you mentioned - but I remember his Brutality one, that blew me away back in the day!
I'll try and make the characters more fluid in the next one, thanks for all that!

[The Ultimate Showdown]

Fairly Good

I think that the reviewers need to remember that you have to vote on each aspect of the movie, not just give it all 10's because the song was entertaining. Not to mention there was less animation involved in it than a Foamy movie. It was amusing, but definately not the greatest.

altffour responds:

I'm not saying it is the greatest a bunch of people at newgrounds are saying it's the greatest why don't you go tell them

[All NG Fads Die!!! 3!!!]

Blah

Graphics: 5, The best graphics were the ones you ripped from other flashes.

Style: 4, the colab movies are getting really old quick. How about killing off that fad?

Sound: 2, also, what about the fad of putting bad and overused music into flash movies (ie Limp Bizkit)? Not to mention the music covered dialogue.

Violence: 7, obvious.

Interactivity: 1, it had a replay feature.

Humor: 2, the only thing that made me even slightly grin was the Salad Fingers part, too bad you could barely hear him speak.

Overall: 5, colab movies are getting old. Take a bunch of sub par animations that would get a 1-2 score on the portal by themselves and throw them together to make a movie. It's old and tired. Kill this fad please.

MACception responds:

Review: 5.

Thanks for going into depth...we'll try to please you a bit more with the next one.

-LP

[Star Wars: RotS]

I don't get it

You just copied Legendary Frogs style. I'm sorry, your jokes weren't even funny.

Xenon responds:

HA HA. How on EARTH have I copied legendary Frog's style AT ALL?! Oh, wait...you said...my jokes weren't funny.

[Lord of the Pimps]

???

Was this left unfinished or something? It seemed to end rather abruptly, and didn't have a replay option at the end. Seems rather unproffesional for a quality flash artist like yourself. Other than that, the movie was pretty decent. The bullet scene was great, but you need to update the artwork quality of your characters.

Ben-Spurgin responds:

Hehe funny that you say that because I actually made it for a client. The only thing I've submitted on here that I got paid for as a matter of fact heheh so I guess it IS proffessional. But thanks tho!

[Itchi!]

Work on it.

It would be a lot better of a movie, if your characters did more than move random body parts and didnt just slide in. Work on it and it'll get much better scores.

md-confessions-san2 responds:

K, thanks for your review.

[A Boy & His Vision Quest]

Excellent job

A nice clean movie with very good direction. An excellent choice in music as well. I hope to see more flash from you in the future.

PauLH responds:

Thanks pal, I am glad you liked it. I will make more stuff in the future, take care.

[Star Wars in 30 seconds 2]

I like

You took what was great about the original and made it even better. Great Job!

BlindxLink responds:

thanks john.

[-Star wars in 30 seconds-]

great!

I'm a huge Star Wars fan and I found this movie to be hilarious. You should make a remake. Great job!

BlindxLink responds:

already did billy

[StarLocks Adventure 2]

Decent

It was just a short movie, not much else to be said. Your graphics were pretty good though, and atleast you incorporated decent sound.

StarLock responds:

I rand out of ideas after the hospital scene, so i just called it quits since i couldn't think of anything. Thanks for your comments.